The Border Film Genre
The term ‘genre’ is generally understood to refer to types of film that share common characteristics relating to theme and style of filmmaking. For instance, mention that a film is a ‘Western’ or a ‘musical’ and most people will instantly understand its basic story-telling conventions. Classifications of genre (and sub-genre) are also used to target potential audiences, determine production and marketing strategies, and to provide film critics with a basis for comparing and judging films.
Genre categories are also employed to identify distinct stages in the historical development of film: typically, first is an experimental phase, next a classical era as the genre blooms (sometimes referred to as a ‘golden age’), followed by the proliferation of sub-genres (such as the ‘Spaghetti Western’) or refinements that tend toward excess and bowdlerization (say, Border Frankenstein meets the Beatles!!). Ultimately, a genre may collapse under the weight of repetition and parody, before slipping into terminal decline. Enterprising filmmakers and critics sometimes revive a genre, which is how we got Neo-noir, for instance.
I decided to nominate 25 canonical films that together constitute the foundational films in my ‘border film genre.’ The list is of course a personal choice, but the following are demonstrably films of quality and distinction as measured by originality, visuals, screenplay, music, performance, and overall impact and significance. In any event, it’s a good place to begin deciding which films to watch.
1936 VAMONOS CON PANCHO VILLA!
Director: Fernando de Fuentes
Subgenre: Revolution
1949 BORDER INCIDENT
Director: Anthony Mann
Migration
1955 ESPALDAS MOJADAS
Director: Alejandro Galindo
Subgenre: Migration
1958 TOUCH OF EVIL
Director: Orson Welles
Subgenre: Crime
1969 THE WILD BUNCH
Director: Sam Peckinpah
Subgenre: Western
1983 EL NORTE
Director: Gregory Nava
Subgenre: Migration
1987 BORN IN EAST LA
Director: Cheech Marin
Subgenre: Comedy
1991 COMO AGUA PARA CHOCOLATE
Director: Alfonso Arau
Subgenre: Revolution
1991 CABEZA DE VACA
Director: Nicolás Echeverria
Subgenre: History
1994 EL JARDIN DEL EDEN
Director: María Novaro
Subgenre: Migration
1995 LONE STAR
Director: John Sayles
Subgenre: Western
1998 LA OTRA CONQUISTA
Director: Salvador Carrasco
Subgenre: History
1998 BAJO CALIFORNIA
Director: Carlos Bolado Muño
Subgenre: Fantasy
2000 TRAFFIC
Director: Stephen Soderburgh
Subgenre: Crime
2003 YO LA PEOR DE TODAS
Director: María Luisa Bemberg
Subgenre: History
2004 AND STARRING PANCHO VILLA …
Director: Bruce Beresford
Subgenre: Western
2008 SLEEP DEALER
Director: Alex Rivera
Subgenre: Fantasy
2008 PURGATORIO
Director: Roberto Rochín
Subgenre: Migration
2009 SIN NOMBRE
Director: Cary Joji Fukunaga
Subgenre: Crime
2010 MACHETE
Director: Robert Rodriguez
Subgenre: Fantasy
2015 SICARIO
Director: Denis Villeneuve
Subgenre: Crime
2015 600 MILLAS
Director: Gabriel Ripstein
Subgenre: Crime
2016 TRANSPECOS
Director: Greg Kwedar
Subgenre: Western
2019 YA NO ESTOY AQUI
Director: Frías de la Parra
Subgenre: Migration
2021 SIN SENAS PARTICULARES
Director: Fernanda Valadez
Subgenre: The ‘Disappeared’